Phillies Face Urgent Bullpen Crisis After Alvarado's 80-Game Suspension

The Philadelphia Phillies are staring down a big challenge after the suspension of their star reliever, Jose Alvarado. He’s out for 80 games without pay after testing positive for exogenous testosterone, which is a banned substance.

This setback has ramped up the Phillies’ urgency to shore up their bullpen before the trade deadline. They’re already in win-now mode with the playoffs looming, so the pressure’s on to find replacements who can keep them ahead.

Table of Contents

The Impact of Alvarado’s Suspension

Alvarado’s suspension leaves a huge gap in the Phillies’ bullpen. He’s known for his blistering fastball and the way he shuts down left-handed hitters.

He was the guy they called on in the highest-leverage spots. Now, that reliability is gone, and the team’s pitching depth and strategy have taken a real hit.

Alvarado’s Role in the Bullpen

Alvarado wasn’t just another reliever—he was their main closer and the top choice against tough lefty hitters. With a 100 mph fastball, a 99 mph sinker, and a 94 mph cutter, he was intimidating on the mound.

This season, he posted the lowest walk rate of his career at 1.8 per nine innings, way down from 4.9 before. His absence leaves a hole that’s not going to be easy to fill.

Immediate Consequences for the Phillies

Now, the Phillies have to count on other bullpen arms to step up. Lefty Matt Strahm and right-handers Jordan Romano and Orion Kerkering are all expected to take on bigger roles while Alvarado sits.

DISCOVER MORE MLB Weighs Reinstatement of All-Time Hit Leader Pete Rose

Strahm, who had a left shoulder impingement in spring, has looked sharp lately. Romano’s been on a roll too, with seven straight scoreless outings, so maybe he becomes the go-to closer for now.

Key Players to Watch

Matt Strahm: Strahm’s outings lately have looked sharp. Manager Rob Thomson even said his stuff looked the best it has all season.
Jordan Romano: Romano’s recent run includes two saves in his last seven games. He could end up closing out more high-pressure innings.
Tanner Banks: Banks moves up the bullpen ladder now. He’s held lefties to a .179 average this year, so he’s definitely someone to keep an eye on.

Trade Deadline Strategies

With Alvarado gone, the Phillies’ need for bullpen help just got urgent. The trade deadline is still 10 weeks away, but they really need a high-leverage reliever—fast.

Problem is, it’s tough to get top arms this far ahead of the deadline. Teams usually have to overpay, and that’s never fun.

Potential Trade Targets

The Phillies have their eyes on a few names, but none of them will come cheap. Here’s who they might be looking at:

Ryan Helsley (Cardinals): Landing Helsley would be expensive, especially now.
Mason Miller (A’s): Miller isn’t a free agent until after 2028, so the A’s would want a huge haul—think top prospects like Aidan Miller and Justin Crawford.
Pete Fairbanks (Rays): The Rays probably won’t move Fairbanks unless someone blows them away with an offer.
Felix Bautista and Yennier Cano (Orioles): Both are valuable to the Orioles, so unless the Phillies put together a massive offer, it’s a long shot.
Kyle Finnegan (Nationals): Finnegan’s an option, but the Nats are in the playoff hunt too, so they’re not likely to deal him early.

DISCOVER MORE Springfield College Women's Gymnastics Shines at Rhode Island Tri-Meet

Challenges and Considerations

President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski knows it’s tough to make trades this early in the season. Most teams still think they’ve got a shot at the postseason, so they’re not eager to give up good relievers unless the return is huge.

The Phillies have to juggle these realities while thinking about both the present and the future.

Balancing Short-Term and Long-Term Needs

Dombrowski pointed out that the team can’t just focus on immediate needs. Sure, they need a high-leverage reliever now, but any deal also has to fit with their long-term plans.

Overpaying for a short-term fix could haunt them later. Finding that balance—addressing what’s urgent without sacrificing the future—isn’t easy, but it’s what the front office has to figure out.

Conclusion: Moving Forward

The suspension of Jose Alvarado hits the Philadelphia Phillies hard. It’s a setback, no doubt about it.

Still, this isn’t their first brush with adversity. The Phillies have a knack for finding ways forward, even when things look rough.

Maybe they’ll shuffle the roster, or maybe a trade’s on the horizon. Either way, they’re not out of the postseason race yet.

If you’re curious about all the details and what it means for the team, check out the full article on NBC Sports Philadelphia.

Joe Hughes is the founder of CollegeNetWorth.com, a comprehensive resource on college athletes' earnings potential in the NIL era. Combining his passion for sports with expertise in collegiate athletics, Joe provides valuable insights for athletes, fans, and institutions navigating this new landscape.

Additional Reading: