In a groundbreaking study published in Management Science, researchers Tim Derdenger from Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business and Ivan Li from the Naveen Jindal School of Management, University of Texas at Dallas, have uncovered compelling evidence that Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) policies are reshaping college football. Contrary to what a lot of folks expected—that NIL would just help elite programs—the study shows these policies are actually spreading opportunities and talent across way more schools. This shift is shaking up the sport’s dynamics, making college football a bit wilder and, honestly, more fun for everyone involved. Wider Distribution of Talent The study dug into recruitment patterns for 3, 4, and 5-star recruits, both before and after NIL. Turns out, talent is spreading out more than before, and that’s a big deal. This wider distribution is giving athletes more ways to build their brands and earn money, which challenges the old idea that NIL would just help the big-name schools get richer. Empowering Lower-Ranked Programs Here’s something surprising: NIL is helping lower-ranked football programs land better recruits, especially among 5-star and lower 4-star athletes. Now, more athletes are weighing their options, thinking about both money and playing time, instead of just chasing a spot at a powerhouse school. They’re looking at financial prospects right alongside their athletic ambitions, and that feels like a healthier market for everyone. Key Findings: Talent is spreading out more across college football programs. Lower-ranked schools are snagging higher-quality recruits. Athletes have more leverage and real choices about where to play. Improved Competitive Balance The study points to better competitive balance since NIL kicked in. Sportsbooks are seeing smaller point spreads for games, even after considering talent, team performance, and transfer portal action. This suggests NIL is creating tighter, more competitive matchups—something fans and players both seem to love. More Exciting and Unpredictable Games With more teams in the mix for top talent, the sport’s just less predictable now. The researchers noticed a real change in how games play out, and honestly, it makes college football feel more alive and up for grabs. Benefits of Improved Competitive Balance: Games are closer and more competitive. Fans are more engaged—there’s more to root for. More teams are in the hunt for top recruits. Influence on Athletes’ Decision-Making The study also digs into how NIL is shaping athletes’ choices. Since NIL, a lot of 3-star recruits are putting NIL earnings ahead of a school’s academic reputation. Plenty are picking colleges with lower SAT averages or less impressive graduate incomes, which really shows how much NIL is changing the game. Strategic Choices for Financial Benefits Athletes now have more say in where they go, and they’re thinking hard about what matters most—sometimes it’s money, sometimes it’s playing time, sometimes it’s both. This new landscape means players are weighing immediate financial perks against long-term goals in ways that just weren’t possible before. Factors Influencing Athletes’ Choices: Quick financial gains from NIL deals. How well a school fits with their personal goals. Thinking about life after football, too—at least some of the time. Policy Recommendations The study tosses out a few ideas for making things fairer and keeping the playing field even. Policymakers should push for NIL adoption everywhere and set up rules that require collectives to register and be transparent about deals. They also suggest schools should educate athletes about NIL contracts, offer counseling, and keep an eye on how things are evolving with regular research and policy tweaks. Steps for Policymakers: There are a few things policymakers can do to make college football fairer and more competitive. It’s about making sure more athletes really get something out of the new NIL rules, not just a select few. Recommended Actions: Push for NIL adoption in every program, not just the big names. Set up actual, enforceable rules for collectives—no loopholes. Make it mandatory for all NIL deals to be registered and disclosed. No exceptions. Focus on teaching student-athletes what NIL really means for them. They deserve to know. Keep an eye on how NIL changes things over time. Regular research isn’t optional. If you want to dig deeper into the study and see all the details, check out the full article on Phys.org.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
