There’s been a new twist in the world of college football. A Virginia Tech player has hired NIL attorney Darren Heitner to push back against the school’s decision to label his redshirting as “opting out.”
This move ended his scholarship and cut off revenue-sharing payments. It’s stirred up plenty of debate and highlighted just how tangled NIL agreements and player rights have become in college sports.
The Controversy: Redshirting vs. Opting Out
Redshirting’s nothing new—it lets athletes sit out a season to keep a year of eligibility. But Virginia Tech’s recent choice to call a player’s redshirt an “opt out” has left a lot of people scratching their heads.
Heitner argues the university’s position doesn’t hold water. He points out that NCAA bylaws don’t treat redshirting the same as voluntarily leaving a program.
Darren Heitner’s Involvement
Darren Heitner is well-known for his work on NIL cases. He didn’t hide his surprise on X, saying redshirting shouldn’t be grounds for yanking scholarships or revenue-sharing.
He’s decided to take the case head-on, hoping to overturn Virginia Tech’s call. He’s even offered to help other athletes in the same boat.
Implications for the Player
The player wants to redshirt but still stick with the team and practice. He’s not looking to redshirt and immediately jump into the transfer portal, which is usually how things go.
His plan is to stay put, which makes the university’s “opting out” label even more confusing.
Financial Motivations
Money’s clearly a big part of all this. Is the player just waiting out the season to collect some checks, or is he thinking long-term about his development?
Virginia Tech’s move to pull his scholarship and cut off payments suggests there’s more at play here than just athletic policy.
Legal and Athletic Ramifications
If this “opting out” label sticks, it could ripple across college sports. Other schools might follow suit, changing how they handle redshirting and scholarships.
It also brings up some tough questions about whether it’s fair—or even legal—to end scholarships and revenue deals in these cases.
Program’s Response
So far, Virginia Tech hasn’t said much. The athletic department has taken the player off the roster and limited his access to team resources, which just adds to the mess.
Legal experts and fans alike are watching closely, and criticism is piling up.
Transfer Portal Dynamics
With the recent firing of head coach Brent Pry, Virginia Tech players who still have eligibility now get a 30-day window to hit the transfer portal. Some are taking advantage—true juniors like cornerback Dante Lovett and linebacker Michael Short have already announced they’re transferring.
They’ll get two more years of eligibility wherever they land, which makes transferring an attractive option.
Medical Redshirt Considerations
Tucker Holloway, a wide receiver and punt returner, isn’t a true junior but redshirted in 2024 after a leg injury. Thanks to a medical redshirt, he’s got two years of eligibility left too.
This just adds another layer to the already complicated situation around redshirting and eligibility.
Future Developments
As things move forward, there’s bound to be more info coming out. Heitner’s challenge could shake up how schools handle redshirting and NIL deals.
Plenty of eyes—players, coaches, and lawyers—are watching to see what happens next.
The dispute between the Virginia Tech player and the university over whether redshirting counts as opting out shows just how much college athletics is changing these days.
NIL agreements and player rights are getting more tangled every season. This case might actually set the tone for how similar situations play out down the road.
If you want to dig deeper into what’s happening, check out the full article on Sports Illustrated.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
