**Title: Why We Are Already Annoyed About CFP Rankings**
As the college football season rolls on, the release of the College Football Playoff (CFP) rankings always seems to spark a mess of emotions. Fans, analysts, and teams get caught up in the drama every single time.
Sports Illustrated recently pointed out why people get annoyed so early with the CFP rankings. The article digs into the inconsistencies and biases that keep popping up in the system.
Inconsistencies in the CFP Rankings
The rankings frustrate people mostly because they just aren’t consistent. Every year, the criteria for ranking teams seem to shift for reasons that aren’t always clear.
The committee says it considers things like strength of schedule, head-to-head results, and conference championships. But how much each factor matters can change from week to week, and that’s confusing.
Strength of Schedule
Strength of schedule is supposed to matter a lot. But sometimes, it doesn’t get applied evenly.
Power Five teams usually play tougher opponents, but that doesn’t always help their ranking. A team with a couple losses in a hard conference might still end up below an undefeated team from a weaker league, even if they’ve faced way better competition.
Head-to-Head Results
Head-to-head results should be straightforward. If Team A beats Team B, shouldn’t Team A be ranked higher?
But the committee doesn’t always follow that logic. Sometimes other factors come into play, and fans start to wonder what’s really going on.
Biases and Perceptions
Bias creeps in too, and it’s hard to ignore. Committee members are human, and they bring their own opinions about certain teams and conferences.
That can lead to rankings that favor the usual powerhouses, while scrappy underdogs get left out in the cold.
Power Five Bias
The Power Five conferences—ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-12, and SEC—almost always dominate the rankings. Sure, they’re strong, but that bias can leave Group of Five teams on the outside looking in, no matter how well they play.
People just assume Power Five teams are better. That perception shapes the rankings, even when the records say otherwise.
Historical Success
Teams with a big-time history get the benefit of the doubt. A famous program with a loyal following might get ranked higher than a lesser-known team, even if the records are about the same—or better for the underdog.
This focus on tradition can keep new programs from getting their shot. It’s tough to break through when the deck feels stacked.
Impact on the Playoff Picture
These inconsistencies and biases really mess with the playoff picture. Teams ranked too low might miss their shot at a national championship.
Meanwhile, higher-ranked teams get more attention and opportunities, whether they’ve earned them or not.
Exclusion of Deserving Teams
Leaving out deserving teams just doesn’t sit right. Fans and players start to question whether the rankings mean anything at all.
It’s tough to trust the process when it seems so arbitrary.
Increased Pressure on Coaches and Players
The rankings add a ton of stress for coaches and players. They know the committee’s opinions could make or break their season.
That kind of pressure can mess with performance on the field. Sometimes, it even drags down the quality of the games we all want to watch.
Embracing Change
The world of college football never stops shifting. The CFP system really ought to keep up.
Expanding the playoff field could shake things up in a good way. Maybe it’s time to try out advanced metrics too, just to see if they make rankings feel more fair.
Honestly, staying open to new ideas seems like the only way to keep the CFP relevant. If we don’t adapt, future fans might not care as much, and that’d be a shame.
For more thoughts on why the CFP rankings already bug so many people, here’s a detailed analysis from Sports Illustrated.
Anyway, safe travels out there, and hope you catch some great games this season!
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
