In a college football season swirling with chaos and controversy, the debate over expanding the College Football Playoff to 16 teams is louder than ever. This year’s bubble teams—Notre Dame, Alabama, Texas, Vanderbilt, BYU, Miami, and a few more—have each made a solid case for inclusion.
With the selection committee about to lock in the current 12-team bracket, you can feel the angst and heartbreak among fan bases. The playoff’s future structure is still up in the air, and the 2025 season is basically a snapshot of the sport’s weird state of flux.
Let’s dig into why a 16-team playoff just makes sense, especially after what we’ve seen this year.
The Current State of the College Football Playoff
The College Football Playoff (CFP) has sparked heated debate ever since it started. This season, the bubble is even messier, with a mix of old powerhouses and up-and-coming programs all jockeying for a spot.
The current 12-team format is stirring up plenty of anxiety as fans and teams wait for the selection committee to make their picks.
Why the 12-Team Format Falls Short
The 12-team format is better than the old BCS setup, but honestly, it’s still lacking. This year, the bubble is crowded with teams like Notre Dame, Alabama, Texas, Vanderbilt, BYU, and Miami—each with a story, but some will get left out.
The selection process feels pretty arbitrary at times, and there’s a lot of noise about who deserves to be in.
The Case for a 16-Team Playoff
Bumping the playoff up to 16 teams would fix a lot of these problems. More teams means more opportunities for programs that actually deserve a shot at the national championship.
Take Notre Dame, with arguably the nation’s best running back, or Vanderbilt, whose quarterback is basically the heart of the team. A bigger bracket gives them a real chance to show what they’ve got on the big stage.
Teams on the Bubble
This year’s bubble teams really highlight what a 16-team playoff could add. Each one brings something different, and honestly, it’d make for a way more interesting postseason.
Notre Dame
Notre Dame’s running back is a force, making them a tough matchup for anyone. Still, they’re stuck on the bubble, which kind of shows how limited the current playoff setup is.
Alabama
Alabama’s schedule has been brutal, yet here they are, sweating it out on the edge. If we’re being fair, a 16-team playoff would make sure a storied program like this gets a shot at the title.
Texas
Texas, with Steve Sarkisian at the helm, has had a wild ride this season. They even scheduled a non-conference game against Ohio State—talk about ambition.
Shouldn’t teams that take risks like that be rewarded? A bigger playoff would help.
The Impact of NIL and the Transfer Portal
Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals and the transfer portal have totally changed college football. These new rules let teams build competitive rosters pretty fast.
Leveling the Playing Field
The transfer portal lets players move around freely, and NIL deals give them financial incentive to pick a school. It’s helped teams like BYU, who are rolling with a freshman quarterback, stay competitive.
With a 16-team playoff, more of these revamped teams would get their shot.
More Competitive Balance
The gap between the No. 8 and No. 15 ranked teams isn’t what it used to be. Parity is up, and that’s a strong argument for letting more teams in.
Honestly, closer games and more unpredictability would make the postseason way more fun.
The Financial Incentive
Let’s be real: expanding the playoff isn’t just about fairness. There’s a lot of money at stake.
College football is more popular than ever, and a bigger playoff would bring in even more revenue.
Increased Revenue
More playoff games mean more TV contracts, ticket sales, and merch. The financial upside of a 16-team playoff is hard to ignore, especially when money talks louder than ever in college sports.
Growing the Sport
And yeah, a bigger playoff means more fan bases get invested. More teams in the hunt means more regional buzz and better TV ratings.
That kind of engagement could only help college football keep growing.
Conclusion
The debate over expanding the College Football Playoff to 16 teams? It’s more relevant than ever, honestly.
This year’s bubble teams have sparked plenty of arguments. Add in the impact of NIL and the transfer portal, and things get even messier.
Financial incentives are swirling around too, making the case for change hard to ignore. If you’re curious and want to dig deeper, check out the original article on Bleacher Report.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
