The world of college sports is a mess. It’s confusing, chaotic, and honestly, the business model just doesn’t work.
Unregulated bidding for coaches and athletes, plus the murky business of NIL deals, have turned college athletics into something almost unrecognizable. It used to feel organized and fair—now, not so much.
The Broken Business Model of College Sports
College sports might have built the worst business model out there. Problems are everywhere, including:
- Unregulated Bidding System: Coaches and athletes can jump ship whenever they want, always angling for better offers.
- Lack of Player Compensation: Players aren’t paid for playing football. Instead, they get money for their “marketing rights,” which just creates headaches when contracts go bad.
- Inconsistent Payroll Regulations: There’s supposed to be a third-party clearinghouse to keep payrolls in check and things balanced. But honestly, it doesn’t really enforce much—legal threats usually scare them off.
- Donor Dependency: Schools are stuck relying on donors to pay players. It’s a cycle that feels unstable and risky.
The Transfer Portal Chaos
The transfer portal? It’s made things even wilder. About a third of college football players are in the portal at any given time.
Teams scramble to keep up, but with constant roster turnover, building a solid, cohesive squad is nearly impossible.
High-Stakes NIL Deals
Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals were supposed to help athletes get a fair cut. Instead, they’ve unleashed a free-for-all with barely any rules.
Quarterbacks Commanding Millions
Now, quarterbacks are landing $4–5 million deals—basically what a top NFL rookie might get. None of it is guaranteed, though, so there’s a lot of risk for everyone involved.
Look at Washington’s situation: quarterback Demond Williams signed a revenue-sharing deal, then announced he was hitting the transfer portal to chase even bigger money. Total chaos.
The Role of Marketing Companies
Universities have started using marketing companies to build financial packages for athletes. This lets them go over the revenue-share cap set by settlements like House v. NCAA.
- Excessive Financial Packages: These companies put together deals that blow right past the agreed caps.
- Legal Vulnerabilities: Schools end up more exposed to lawsuits and accusations of collusion.
The Tennessee Volunteer Club Incident
Remember Tennessee’s Volunteer Club? On National Signing Day, a recruit got offered $85,000 in stipends, a paid apartment, and $25,000 for agent fees—allegedly signed by his grandma.
It’s a pretty clear sign that the rules are fuzzy at best, and mistakes (or outright cheating) are easy to make.
The NCAA’s Inaction
The NCAA? They’ve mostly just shrugged, waiting for Congress to bail them out with new laws. But with everything else going on in Washington, that seems like wishful thinking.
Legal and Regulatory Challenges
The NCAA has been lobbying Congress for over six years, but nothing’s changed. Its enforcement arm is weak, so policing the mess is almost impossible.
- Lobbying Efforts: Years of lobbying, zero progress.
- Enforcement Issues: Not much bite left in their rulebook.
The Need for a Complete Overhaul
University presidents and athletic directors have mostly dodged the hard truth: the old amateurism model is broken. It needs to be stripped down and rebuilt from scratch.
Building a Fair and Sustainable System
If college sports are ever going to work, they’ll need to:
- Fair Compensation: Pay players what they’re worth, and treat them like pros.
- Accountability: Make sure everyone stands by the contracts they sign, maybe through collective bargaining.
- Regulation and Oversight: Set up real oversight to keep things fair and balanced.
Conclusion
College sports are in a rough spot these days. Years of questionable choices and stubbornness have left things, well, a bit of a mess.
The business model? It’s shaky at best, focused more on quick wins than actually building something that lasts. Players aren’t treated like the professionals they really are, and that just doesn’t sit right with a lot of folks.
There’s a growing sense that it’s time for a real change. People want to see athletes paid fairly and the whole system held to higher standards.
If you’re curious about the full story, check out the article on Yahoo Sports. It’s worth a read.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
