The 2023 MLB season has thrown a few curveballs, especially when it comes to pitchers who were supposed to dominate the mound. Some of these guys just haven’t lived up to the hype so far.
Let’s dig into what’s going wrong for them. We’ll look at the numbers, toss around a few theories, and see if there’s any hope for a turnaround.
Analyzing Pitching Metrics
When you’re sizing up a pitcher, a handful of stats matter most. ERA (Earned Run Average), WHIP (Walks plus Hits per Inning Pitched), and FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) top the list.
Wins and losses can be misleading since team performance plays a role, but those main metrics really show what a pitcher brings to the table.
ERA and WHIP
ERA and WHIP are usually the first numbers anyone checks. A high ERA? That means the pitcher’s letting in too many earned runs. A high WHIP? Too many baserunners.
But it’s not always so simple. Defense, the ballpark, and even plain old luck can mess with these numbers.
Sometimes, a pitcher with a high WHIP but a low ERA gets saved by solid defense. Other times, a low WHIP and high ERA means bad luck or lousy fielding behind them. It’s never just one thing, is it?
FIP: A Deeper Dive
FIP tries to strip away all the noise and focus on what a pitcher can actually control: strikeouts, unintentional walks, hit-by-pitches, and home runs. It ignores fielding, which honestly feels fairer to the pitcher.
If you see a pitcher with a high ERA but a low FIP, maybe they’re just having a run of bad luck. Flip it, and a low ERA with a high FIP might mean some regression is coming. Baseball can be cruel that way.
Top Underperforming Pitchers
So, who’s been having a rough go of it? Yahoo Sports recently pointed out five pitchers who just haven’t hit their stride. These guys were supposed to be big-time contributors, but things haven’t gone as planned.
Pitcher 1: The High-Profile Ace
This guy came in with a massive contract and all eyes on him. Instead, he’s got a high ERA and WHIP, so the adjustment to his new team hasn’t been smooth.
But his FIP? Still pretty low. If he can cut down on walks and keep the ball in the park, there’s a chance he figures it out.
Pitcher 2: The Veteran Struggler
This veteran’s been a steady presence for years, but now his numbers have ballooned. Both his ERA and WHIP are up, and his FIP doesn’t offer much hope either.
Is age catching up, or is it just a bad stretch? Hard to say at this point.
Pitcher 3: The Young Phenom
Last season, this young arm broke out in a big way. Expectations soared, but now he’s fighting control problems, and both his WHIP and ERA have climbed.
He’s still racking up strikeouts, so if he finds his command, maybe things turn around. It’s not impossible.
Pitcher 4: The Injury Comeback
He’s back from a major injury, but it’s been tough sledding so far. ERA and WHIP are both higher than you’d like, and the FIP isn’t much kinder.
Maybe he just needs a little more time to get back in the groove. Coming back from injury is never easy.
Pitcher 5: The Inconsistent Performer
This pitcher is a wild card. One night he’s lights out, the next he’s getting shelled.
His stats bounce all over the place, and the FIP says he’s probably somewhere in the middle talent-wise. If he can string together some steady outings, who knows?
Factors Contributing to Underperformance
Why do pitchers struggle? There’s never just one answer. Mechanical tweaks, pitch selection, and even what’s going on in their heads can all play a part.
Mechanical Issues
Pitching mechanics are tricky. Even a slight change in arm angle or stride can mess with control and velocity.
Coaches and video analysis can help, but fixing these things isn’t instant. Sometimes it takes a while before it shows up in the box score.
Changes in Pitch Usage
Pitchers sometimes shift their approach—maybe throwing fewer fastballs and leaning into off-speed stuff, or the other way around. These changes could come from scouting advice, personal preference, or even to protect an injury.
Digging into pitch mix can reveal a lot about what’s really going on out there.
Mental Factors
Confidence is huge. A couple bad games can get in a pitcher’s head and spiral from there.
Support from teammates and mental coaches can help, but it’s not always a quick fix. Baseball’s as much mental as it is physical, isn’t it?
Looking Ahead
The MLB season drags on, and honestly, there’s still a lot of runway left for these struggling pitchers. If they can sort out what’s holding them back, there’s a real shot they could help their teams get back on track.
Maybe you’re curious. Maybe you’re skeptical. Either way, it’s worth keeping an eye on these guys—sometimes a midseason rebound sneaks up on everyone.
If you want to dive deeper or just keep tabs on their progress, here’s a solid article with more details: MLB pitchers underperforming based on key metrics.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
