In a groundbreaking decision, U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney in Colorado issued a preliminary injunction that’s sent shockwaves through the college football world. This ruling allows members of the 2022 recruiting class who used up their eligibility after four straight seasons to return to college football in 2026.
The ruling comes from a lawsuit by athletes who argued they were unfairly excluded under the NCAA’s new age-based eligibility model. It opens the door for plenty of players to make a comeback, but also drops a pile of logistical and strategic headaches on college programs.
The Ruling and Its Implications
The preliminary injunction issued last Friday has really changed the landscape of college football by letting certain players return for another season. It specifically covers athletes from the 2022 recruiting class who didn’t redshirt and were previously out of eligibility under the old NCAA rules.
While this decision offers a second shot for many, it comes with its own set of conditions and limitations. Nothing here is simple, and there’s definitely a catch or two.
Conditions for Returning Players
Players who want to come back generally need to rejoin the school where they played during the 2025 season. The transfer portal is closed to athletes who weren’t already in it, and anyone who’s signed a pro contract—like with the NFL or CFL—can’t return.
Just showing up at a rookie minicamp doesn’t affect eligibility, though. That’s a bit of a loophole, honestly.
Schools’ Obligations and Challenges
Schools aren’t required to make room for returning athletes. Most programs have already put together their 2026 rosters and are gearing up for fall camp.
The NCAA is expected to appeal the injunction, which just adds more uncertainty to an already messy situation.
Players Expressing Interest in Returning
According to CBS Sports’ Chris Hummer and Matt Zenitz, more than a dozen FBS players have already shown interest in coming back under the new ruling. Here are some notable names and their possible paths back to the field:
Florida State’s Quarterback Situation
The former starting quarterback at Florida State wants to return, but his roster spot is already filled. After he used up his eligibility, the Seminoles brought in veteran transfer Ashton Daniels from Stanford and Auburn, who’s set to start Week 0 in 2026.
Honestly, it wouldn’t make much sense for Florida State to bring back their old quarterback just 26 days before the opener. The timing is just off.
Virginia’s Defensive Front
Virginia, which has the most experienced roster in the entire FBS, could use more depth on the defensive front. Holmes and Moore, who played meaningful snaps for the Cavaliers in 2025, might return.
Holmes, especially, would bring over 1,100 career snaps to the team. That’s not something you just find on the street.
Texas Longhorns’ Offensive Line
The path is pretty clear for Hutson to rejoin the Longhorns. Texas coach Steve Sarkisian has said he values bringing back a player with Hutson’s experience.
Hutson has played in 48 games and made 23 career starts at Texas, mostly at right guard but also at center. His return would make him the most experienced player on Texas’ 2026 roster.
TCU’s Secondary
Jordan, who started 12 games at nickelback for the Horned Frogs in 2025, could return to add more depth to an already experienced secondary. TCU has two returning starters and a transfer who was Conference USA’s Co-Defensive Player of the Year in 2025.
There’s a position battle brewing for the starting nickel spot, so Jordan’s return isn’t a simple yes or no. It’s complicated.
Ohio State’s Kicking Room
Fielding, despite his strong résumé, probably won’t return to Ohio State. The Buckeyes have already rebuilt their kicking room with transfers and a freshman.
Fielding handled Ohio State’s place-kicking for the past three years, leading the team in scoring each season. But at this point, a late change seems pretty unlikely.
Kansas’ Defensive Line
Kansas has to replace every starter from its defensive line, so Finkley is an intriguing potential return. After transferring from Texas ahead of the 2025 season, he started all 12 games for Kansas.
His experience would be a huge boost for the Jayhawks’ defensive front.
Arizona State’s Secondary
Arizona State went all-in on retooling its secondary this offseason, but Rowser’s return would instantly make him the most experienced defensive back on the roster. Rowser started 12 games in 2025 and logged more defensive snaps than any Sun Devils player last season.
His experience could be invaluable for a secondary that’s seen a lot of turnover.
Houston’s Kicking Game
Houston could use Sanchez back after he turned in one of the best seasons by a kicker in school history. The Cougars added former Florida kicker Evan Noel this offseason, but Sanchez is still the more proven option.
He was a Lou Groza Award semifinalist and nailed three game-winning field goals in 2025. That’s the kind of clutch you want.
Georgia’s Safety Depth
Thomas, who went undrafted but took part in rookie minicamp with the Carolina Panthers, could still return to Georgia if there’s an open spot. He played in all 14 games and made eight starts at safety last season.
His return would give Georgia more depth at a position that’s already added new faces from the transfer portal.
The preliminary injunction lets members of the 2022 recruiting class return to college football in 2026. That’s a big deal for a lot of athletes hoping for a second shot.
But let’s be honest, this move is throwing college programs into a scramble. Coaches and schools now face some real headaches as they try to reshuffle rosters and manage unexpected eligibility changes.
The NCAA isn’t just watching from the sidelines—they’re gearing up to appeal. Nobody really knows how this will play out, but it’s clear the next season could get wild.
If you want to dig into the details or just see all the twists and turns, check out the full article on CBS Sports.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
