As we move deeper into the digital age, American college sports are changing fast. The introduction of Name, Image, Likeness (NIL) policies has shaken up the landscape in ways nobody saw coming.
These policies let college athletes make money from their personal brands. For some of the most talented players, that means serious financial gains.
This article digs into how NIL valuations have evolved. We’ll look at how these changes are affecting student-athletes and the broader college sports world.
The Evolution of NIL in College Sports
Amateurism in college sports has always sparked debate. For years, student-athletes weren’t allowed to earn money, even though their games brought in huge revenue for their schools.
This imbalance led to criticism and legal fights, including the 2009 lawsuit by former UCLA basketball star Ed O’Bannon. When O’Bannon’s case was settled in 2015, it set the stage for change and, eventually, the launch of NIL policies on July 1, 2021.
The Financial Impact of NIL Policies
Since NIL took effect, the money picture for college athletes has changed a lot. According to BNN Bloomberg, at least 20 college quarterbacks made over $2 million before taxes in 2025.
This kind of earning power isn’t just changing athletes’ lives—it’s shaking up the whole college sports scene.
Top NIL Valuations in 2025
Arch Manning: Leading the Pack
Arch Manning, Texas Longhorns quarterback, sits at the top in 2025 with an On3 NIL valuation of $5.3 million. Even though his team missed the College Football Playoff, Manning’s bank account is proof that NIL can be a game-changer for top athletes.
He might even stay in college another year, despite being a likely Number-1 pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. NIL cash can definitely make that decision a little easier.
Fernando Mendoza: A Rising Star
Fernando Mendoza, the Heisman-winning quarterback for the Indiana Hoosiers, is another big name. On3 puts his value at $2.6 million, boosted by a late-season adidas deal.
He led the Hoosiers to their first Big Ten title since 1967, bumping up both his draft prospects and his marketability.
AJ Dybantsa: Basketball’s Top Earner
On the basketball side, AJ Dybantsa from BYU leads with a $4.4 million NIL valuation. He’s landed deals with Nike and Red Bull, and his choice to play for BYU instead of Duke or North Carolina seems to have paid off.
He’s the clear star on campus, and his success shows how smart moves can really maximize NIL earnings.
The Broader Implications of NIL
Impact on College Programs and Coaches
NIL has hit college programs and coaches hard, too. With players now making real money, recruiting and team management have gotten trickier.
Coaches have to juggle helping athletes grow their brands while keeping everyone working together. It’s a new balancing act, and nobody’s totally figured it out yet.
Media and Advertising Opportunities
The media world is changing alongside NIL. Networks and advertisers are jumping at the chance to spotlight star athletes who pull in big audiences.
The Big Ten championship game between Indiana and Ohio State drew almost 20 million viewers—the most ever for that matchup. That’s good for the networks, but it’s also great for athletes, who get more exposure and better endorsement deals.
Challenges and Controversies
Debates Over Fairness
Of course, NIL isn’t all smooth sailing. Some folks argue it’s not fair—big earners might hurt team spirit or widen gaps between athletes.
There’s real concern about how this could shake up the traditional values of college sports.
Regulatory and Compliance Issues
Regulating NIL deals is another headache. Making sure everyone follows NCAA rules and that athletes aren’t getting taken advantage of is a tall order.
Conflicts of interest and the need for transparency in deals are ongoing issues that need close attention.
The Future of NIL in College Sports
Potential for Growth
Looking forward, the ceiling for NIL earnings seems pretty high. As more athletes tap into their entrepreneurial sides, endorsement and sponsorship opportunities will only grow.
Stories like Arch Manning, Fernando Mendoza, and AJ Dybantsa show just how much potential is out there with NIL. Who knows how far this could go?
Long-Term Impact on College Sports
The long-term impact of NIL on college sports? Honestly, it’s still a bit of a mystery. Sure, athletes are seeing immediate financial perks, but the full ripple effect for college sports as a whole will take years to really show itself.
Balancing commercial interests for athletes with the educational and developmental goals of college programs—well, that’s going to be tricky. It’s not just about the money; it’s about keeping the spirit of college sports alive while everything changes around it.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
