The SCORE Act, a significant piece of legislation aimed at creating a uniform national system for college athletics, has recently hit a snag in its journey through Congress.
Originally seen as a promising solution to the fragmented landscape of name, image, and likeness (NIL) regulations, the bill’s momentum has stalled. Its future is looking pretty uncertain right now.
Understanding the SCORE Act
The SCORE Act tries to set up a standardized federal framework for college athletics, especially around NIL regulations. Instead of the current mess of state laws, it would offer a more consistent and predictable environment for schools and athletes.
Key provisions of the bill include:
- Guaranteed scholarships
- Enhanced medical care for injuries
- Post-graduation degree support
- Mental health services for athletes
Another important detail: the bill says college athletes aren’t to be considered employees, which tackles a big NCAA worry. It also offers some antitrust protections for the NCAA and conferences, but only if their rules line up with the new law.
The Promise of Stability
Supporters say the SCORE Act would bring some much-needed stability to a system that’s constantly shifting. High-profile cases like Alston and House have shown just how vulnerable and inconsistent things are right now.
By standardizing NIL regulations, the bill hopes to create a fairer playing field for everyone involved.
Challenges and Opposition
Despite the potential upsides, the SCORE Act faces a lot of pushback. Critics are worried that the antitrust protections go too far, giving the NCAA too much cover from accountability.
There are also concerns the bill could widen the gap between wealthy programs and smaller schools that don’t have as many resources.
Political Hurdles
The bill has made it through two committees but still isn’t scheduled for a full House vote. It started off with nearly unanimous Republican support, which was crucial since most House Democrats lean pro-union.
Lately, though, several Republicans have backed away, and that’s slowed things down.
If the bill does make it through the House, it faces an even steeper climb in the Senate. It would need 60 votes to pass there, and senators like Maria Cantwell are already raising issues about fairness, athlete rights, and the impact on smaller schools.
Impact on Olympic and Non-Revenue Sports
One of the most debated parts of the SCORE Act is what it might mean for Olympic and non-revenue sports. The bill requires Division I schools with revenue over $20 million to sponsor at least 16 varsity teams.
Still, there’s worry that this won’t be enough to protect smaller sports. Some fear schools will just double down on football and basketball, leaving other programs in the dust.
Concerns from Athletes and Advocacy Groups
Athletes.org, a players association, has been pretty vocal against the SCORE Act. They argue the bill limits athlete opportunities by making it tougher for players to earn money, transfer, or really explore the market.
Some of their main issues include:
- Restrictions on NIL deals that get labeled as “prohibited compensation”
- Limits on transfers, with athletes only allowed to switch schools once without penalty
- Capping NIL payments and restricting transfers, which Athletes.org says just props up the NCAA’s old system more than actually helping athletes
Future Legislative Efforts
Even with the SCORE Act’s future up in the air, other federal efforts are bubbling up. Some lawmakers want to let athletes collectively bargain by classifying them as employees.
Others are pushing for stronger NIL protections for international athletes. The U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee is also lobbying hard so Olympic sports don’t get left behind in all this.
Executive Orders and Further Guidance
To complicate things even more, President Trump signed an executive order in July, telling several federal agencies to give guidance on college sports issues. The fallout from this order could end up shaping future laws and the whole college athletics landscape.
What Fans Should Watch For
For college sports fans, the drama swirling around the SCORE Act is something you probably don’t want to miss. There are a few things worth paying attention to:
- Will the House actually schedule a vote on the SCORE Act?
- Are there tweaks coming to the language about NIL, antitrust protections, or athlete rights?
- How will the Senate react, especially since they’ve got those tougher voting thresholds?
If the SCORE Act goes through, it might bring more consistency to NIL rules. On the flip side, it could make the gap between the powerhouse programs and everyone else even bigger, and some folks are worried about what that means for Olympic sports.
Curious for more updates or just want to dig deeper? Check out HoopsHQ for the latest coverage.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
