The debate over Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) rights in college athletics just got a new wrinkle. The Student Compensation and Opportunity through Rights and Endorsements (SCORE) Act has landed, and it’s making waves.
More than 20 conservative organizations are backing this legislative proposal. They see it as a way to untangle the mess of NIL compensation rules.
By giving the NCAA a limited antitrust exemption, the SCORE Act tries to protect it from a flood of lawsuits. At the same time, it makes sure student-athletes aren’t classified as employees.
The goal? Create a single, unified set of NIL rules and replace the confusing patchwork of state laws.
The SCORE Act: A Conservative Approach to NIL Reform
The SCORE Act leans into a conservative philosophy, with its supporters hoping it will fix the current chaos. The bill sets out to:
- Provide a limited antitrust exemption for the NCAA to shield it from lawsuits over eligibility rules.
- Prohibit athletes from becoming employees of their schools, which would block compulsory unionization.
- Treat student-athletes as small business owners instead of unionized workers.
In a letter to House Speaker Rep. Mike Johnson, supporters called the act a “free market, individual liberty, limited government fix” for NIL issues in college sports. That’s a mouthful, but you get the idea.
Why the SCORE Act is Gaining Support
The SCORE Act has drawn nods from groups like the Center for a Free Economy, National Taxpayers Union, and the Competitive Enterprise Institute. They say the bill is a “common-sense way” to bring clarity to NIL rules nationwide.
It’s not just think tanks, either. Several Division I athletic conferences, including those with tighter budgets and some HBCUs, have jumped on board. That kind of support isn’t easy to come by in college sports.
Comparison with the SAFE Act
The SCORE Act isn’t the only game in town. The Student Athlete Fairness and Enforcement (SAFE) Act, mostly backed by Democrats, takes a different approach. Here’s what the SAFE Act proposes:
- Rewrite the 1961 Sports Broadcasting Act to let conferences pool media rights, possibly bringing billions into college sports.
- Classify student-athletes as employees, which could mean unionization.
- Create a national government board to handle negotiations for sports TV and streaming rights.
Supporters of the SCORE Act are skeptical. They warn that the SAFE Act could trigger “frivolous lawsuits” and force student-athletes into unions. There’s also some real concern about the idea of Washington bureaucrats running the show on sports broadcasting deals.
Bipartisan Support and Legislative Progress
Even with political lines drawn, the SCORE Act has managed to pick up some bipartisan support in the House. Introduced back in July, it’s gotten a boost from folks like Sen. Ted Cruz.
The bill includes a revenue-sharing provision. Schools would need to share at least 22 percent of the average annual college sports revenue from the 70 top-earning schools. That’s meant to give student-athletes a fairer cut.
The Path Forward for NIL Reform
For now, the NIL reform debate is far from settled. The SCORE Act could be a step toward something more unified and balanced, but it’s hard to say how things will shake out.
If you want to dig deeper, check out the full article on Fox News.
The introduction of the SCORE Act is shaking up the NIL reform debate. It’s not just another bill—it’s got a real focus on individual liberty and less government interference, which isn’t something you see every day in this space.
Conservative groups are pretty enthusiastic, and there’s even some bipartisan interest. The act’s approach to revenue-sharing feels more balanced than most, at least on paper.
Lawmakers are still hashing out the details, and honestly, who knows where this will land? But the SCORE Act is definitely in the spotlight right now.
We’ll keep an eye on it. The future of college sports could look pretty different, depending on how all this shakes out.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
