Duke University has filed a lawsuit against its quarterback, Darian Mensah, in a move that could shake up college athletics. The dispute centers around a Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) Agreement, and the outcome might just ripple across the entire NIL industry.
Let’s dig into what sparked this legal battle, what’s in the NIL Agreement, and what could happen next.
What Led to the Lawsuit?
When Mensah transferred from Tulane, he and Duke signed a two-year NIL Agreement. That contract was supposed to stay private, but now it’s public as part of the lawsuit’s evidence.
While the payment details are blacked out, most sources say Mensah is owed $4 million each year. He’d announced he was sticking with Duke for the 2026 season, but then, on the very last day, he switched gears and entered the transfer portal. Now, he’s reportedly eyeing the University of Miami.
Duke claims Mensah broke the NIL Agreement by trying to transfer before the contract ended.
Understanding Mensah’s NIL Agreement
NIL agreements let universities use a student-athlete’s name, image, and likeness for things like marketing. But these deals don’t actually hand over ownership—they’re more like a lease than a sale.
Think of it like renting a car. You get to use it, but you don’t own it. That difference matters here.
The Nature of NIL Agreements
These agreements aren’t employment contracts. That’s intentional. If they were, athletes could be seen as employees, opening the door to labor laws, union rights, and a whole pile of regulations.
Universities have steered clear of that, wanting to avoid the baggage that comes with employee status.
Duke’s Decision to Bring a Lawsuit
Even though the NIL Agreement calls for arbitration, Duke went straight to court. They’re after a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) and a Preliminary Injunction (PI) to stop Mensah from transferring.
The court granted the TRO, so Mensah is now stuck in a sort of limbo—he can enter the transfer portal, but he’s blocked from joining another school until the legal dust settles.
The Court’s Rationale
Duke argued that waiting would cause irreparable harm. The court agreed that quick action was needed.
Mensah got very little notice before the TRO hearing. The court decided to keep things as they were until the next hearing, which was bumped up to January 29th.
What Happens Next?
The upcoming hearing will decide if Mensah can join another team. The court has to decide if he actually breached the NIL Agreement and whether stopping him from transferring is really necessary to prevent harm.
Mensah’s Legal Strategy
Mensah’s lawyers will probably zero in on the idea of irreparable harm—basically, harm that money can’t fix. That could mean bankruptcy, losing something you can’t replace, leaking trade secrets, or damaging a reputation.
His contract mentions irreparable harm, but North Carolina law doesn’t always give much weight to those clauses.
Balancing Hardships and Public Interest
The court will weigh who’s hurt more by all this—Mensah or Duke. Mensah’s side will likely argue that being forced to stay at Duke is a bigger deal for him than any loss Duke might face.
This case could shape how schools enforce NIL agreements and whether athletes inch closer to being seen as employees.
Potential Outcomes
If the court says no to the injunction, schools might have a harder time threatening athletes who break NIL deals. But if the court sides with Duke, it could push athletes closer to employee status—something colleges have long resisted.
It’s a tricky moment for college sports, and the repercussions could be felt far beyond Duke’s campus.
Why Duke and Mensah Should Settle
Both sides have plenty of reasons to settle before the hearing. Mensah could end up missing spring practice if things drag out.
Duke’s in a bind, too. If they win, it might mean athletes are seen as employees, which opens a whole new can of worms.
But if Duke loses, that could make NIL agreements tough to enforce. They’re really stuck between a rock and a hard place.
A settlement gives Duke something to show for their trouble—they got a TRO and maybe scared off future problems. All that without risking a court decision that could totally shake up how student-athletes are viewed.
For a more detailed analysis, you can read the full article on State of the U.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
