Future of MLB Umpiring: Embracing Technology and Pursuing Perfection

BOOK AWAY GAME TRAVEL NOW!
Flights | Hotels | Vacation Rentals | Rental Cars | Experiences

The Major League Baseball (MLB) community can’t seem to stop debating after an in-depth review of umpire performance during the 2025 season. An independent panel dove into the data, and now everyone’s talking about the accuracy and consistency of calls on the field.

Let’s take a closer look at what the review found, what it might mean for the game, and a few changes that could shake up baseball umpiring as we know it.

Table of Contents

Overview of the Umpire Performance Review

MLB brought in an independent panel to examine umpire performance throughout the 2025 season. This panel included former players, coaches, and statistical analysts.

They focused on how accurate the calls were, how consistent umpiring stayed from game to game, and whether any biases crept into decisions.

The results were honestly pretty surprising. The report called out several areas where umpire performance swung widely, showing off both strengths and some glaring weaknesses in the system.

Key Findings

The review flagged a handful of important points:

Accuracy of Calls: Umpires got it right about 94.2% of the time. That’s a bit better than before, but mistakes still happen.
Consistency: Calls weren’t always consistent, especially with strike zones. It seemed to depend a lot on who was behind the plate.
Biases: The report hinted at possible biases favoring home teams and a few high-profile players, though the evidence wasn’t exactly rock solid.
Technological Assistance: Technology like instant replay and automated strike zones boosted accuracy, but also brought new headaches and slowed things down.

Implications for Major League Baseball

This review could mean big changes for MLB. The league has always valued the human side of umpiring, but with everyone watching and expecting perfection, technology’s role is growing whether people like it or not.

Potential Changes on the Horizon

So what might actually change after this review? Here are a few ideas people keep tossing around:

Expanded Use of Technology: Bringing in automated strike zones and more instant replay could cut down on human mistakes.
Umpire Training and Evaluation: Better training and tougher evaluations might help umpires get more calls right and keep things consistent.
Transparency and Accountability: Making umpire performance reviews public and holding umpires more accountable could help restore trust with players, coaches, and fans.

The Role of Technology in Modern Umpiring

Tech is everywhere in sports now, and baseball’s no exception. The review made it clear that technology brings both upsides and headaches to umpiring.

Benefits of Technological Integration

There are some real perks to using more tech, like instant replay and automated strike zones:

Increased Accuracy: Technology helps get calls right more often, shrinking the error margin.
Consistency: Automated systems can keep strike zones steady, so you don’t get wild differences from one umpire to the next.
Fairness: With less bias, technology can help level the playing field for everyone.

Challenges and Concerns

But, let’s be honest, it’s not all smooth sailing with tech either:

Delays: Instant replay and other tools can slow down the game, sometimes to a crawl.
Technical Issues: Technology isn’t perfect. Glitches happen, and those can spark even more controversy.
Human Element: Some die-hard fans say the human touch is part of what makes baseball special. Take that away, and do you lose something?

Conclusion: The Future of Umpiring in MLB

The 2025 MLB season’s umpire performance review kicked off a pretty crucial conversation about where umpiring goes from here. There’s plenty to talk about—improvements are needed, sure, but there’s also this whole thing about keeping the human side of baseball alive, even as tech keeps creeping in.

MLB isn’t standing still. They’re working on new tech and rethinking how they train and evaluate umpires. If you want to dive deeper into the review or just see what all the fuss is about, check out the full report here.

Joe Hughes is the founder of CollegeNetWorth.com, a comprehensive resource on college athletes' earnings potential in the NIL era. Combining his passion for sports with expertise in collegiate athletics, Joe provides valuable insights for athletes, fans, and institutions navigating this new landscape.

Additional Reading: