In a bold legal move, a group of journalists is suing Louisiana State University (LSU) for access to records that show how public funds are spent on college athletes. The lawsuit was filed by Louisiana Illuminator reporter Piper Hutchinson, WAFB-TV investigative reporter Chris Nakamoto, and Tiger Rag Executive Editor Todd Horne.
They’re represented by attorney Scott Sternberg. The journalists say the public deserves to know where taxpayer money goes, especially now that direct payments to student-athletes are allowed.
LSU, on the other hand, claims that these records are protected by law. The university insists that releasing them would hurt its competitive edge.
The Legal Battle for Transparency
The lawsuit was filed in the 19th Judicial District Court in Baton Rouge. It asks the court to force LSU to release records on how it spends public money on student-athletes.
The journalists first tried to get these records through Louisiana’s public records law but got denied. Sternberg puts it simply: *the expenditure of public funds is what government transparency laws are all, at their bedrock, fundamentally about.*
The Argument for Public Access
The main argument is that LSU’s revenue is public money. So, the public should know how those funds are used.
Sternberg said, *asking for records of how Louisiana government, including LSU, spends state dollars is usually not a question.*
Why LSU is Resisting
LSU’s legal team says the records are exempt from disclosure for a few reasons:
- Federal Student Privacy Law: LSU argues that releasing these records would break federal laws that protect student privacy.
- State Law Exemptions: They also point to a state law that exempts name, image, and likeness (NIL) agreements from being made public.
- Competitive Disadvantage: LSU claims that sharing this information would put its athletic programs at a disadvantage.
Meg Sunstrom, an LSU spokeswoman, said, *releasing this information puts LSU at a competitive disadvantage on the field and runs contrary to the privacy interest of our student-athletes.*
LSU’s Financial Landscape
LSU’s athletics department mostly runs on self-generated revenue like ticket sales and media rights. Still, it does get some taxpayer funding.
All this revenue is considered public money and needs legislative approval before being spent. Of the LSU System’s $1.2 billion budget for this year, over $800 million comes from self-generated revenue, mainly from tuition and fees.
The Public’s Right to Know
The Louisiana Constitution says people have the right to examine public documents, with some exceptions. Historically, spending public funds has been open to public scrutiny.
The lawsuit argues that *the public has a compelling interest in understanding how much public money is being expended and to whom.*
Previous Transparency Issues
LSU has previously given the Louisiana Illuminator records about students, including student-athletes, in other public records requests. That history makes their current resistance a bit puzzling.
There’s no blanket exception in state law for information that might create a competitive disadvantage. LSU also regularly releases info about payments to vendors and employees, even high-profile ones like President Wade Rousse and head football coach Lane Kiffin, without saying it harms the university.
The Impact of House v. NCAA
The House v. NCAA settlement last June changed college athletics in a big way. Now, athletics departments can pay athletes directly.
LSU is allowed to spend up to $20.5 million on its players. This shift has only made the debate over transparency in college sports more heated.
What the Lawsuit Seeks
The lawsuit isn’t after records about NIL deals between athletes and private companies—those are exempt from disclosure. The journalists just want to see records on how public money is spent.
Sternberg put it this way: *these news organizations have joined together to file suit because they believe the public’s right to know how our money is spent is sacred.*
Conclusion
This lawsuit marks a big moment in the ongoing debate about transparency in college athletics.
It’ll be interesting to see how the courts handle the tension between the public’s right to know and the privacy of student-athletes. Universities also have their own competitive concerns, which just adds another layer to the whole thing.
If you’re curious and want the full story, check out the article on the Louisiana Illuminator.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
