Michigan football fans got a bit of a curveball this week: Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi, one of the transfer quarterbacks folks were eager to see, won’t be enrolling until the spring-summer term. That leaves the Wolverines with a pretty green quarterback group as spring practice gets underway.
Fowler-Nicolosi, who came over from Colorado State, was supposed to be the backup for Michigan’s new starting quarterback, Bryce Underwood. Now, with his arrival pushed back, new head coach Kyle Whittingham and his staff have to figure out how to patch things up in the meantime.
So, what does all this mean for Michigan as they gear up for the season?
Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi’s Delayed Enrollment
Fowler-Nicolosi was part of Michigan’s big 19-player transfer class announced back in January. But when the spring roster dropped on Tuesday, his name was nowhere to be found.
Team spokesman Dave Ablauf confirmed the delay—Fowler-Nicolosi won’t join until the spring-summer term. That leaves Bryce Underwood, the clear No. 1, without a veteran backup for now.
Impact on Michigan’s Quarterback Room
Fowler-Nicolosi’s absence is a pretty big deal for a few reasons:
- Experience Gap: Without him, Michigan’s quarterbacks are basically all untested. None of the backups have played a college snap.
- Backup Uncertainty: True freshman Tommy Carr, who just enrolled in January, might be the backup. That’s a lot to ask from a kid fresh out of high school.
- Depth Concerns: There are six quarterbacks on the roster, but only Colin Hurley (a transfer from LSU) has actually been practicing. Brady Smigiel, another freshman, is still rehabbing from an ACL injury.
Michigan’s Quarterback Depth Chart
With Fowler-Nicolosi delayed, here’s how things are looking right now:
1. Bryce Underwood
Underwood, a former five-star recruit, is the starter. He threw for 2,428 yards and 11 touchdowns as a true freshman, but he also had nine interceptions. He’s got talent, but he’s still learning.
2. Tommy Carr
Tommy Carr, the local kid from Saline, has turned some heads in spring practice. Coach Whittingham likes his skillset, but let’s be real—he’s never played at this level before.
3. Colin Hurley
Colin Hurley transferred in from LSU and is practicing with the team. He brings some depth, though he’s also never seen game action in college.
4. Chase Herbstreit
Herbstreit’s on the list too, but he’s another guy without college snaps. Hard to say what his role will be just yet.
5. Brady Smigiel
Smigiel, a true freshman, is still working his way back from an ACL injury. No word on whether he’ll be ready for the season.
Kyle Whittingham’s Approach
Since taking over in late December, Kyle Whittingham hasn’t wasted any time shaking things up. He’s clearly going for a win-now mindset, but the quarterback situation is still a big question mark.
Roster Overhaul
Whittingham’s arrival led to a major roster shakeup, especially at quarterback. Four experienced QBs left via the transfer portal—including former starter Davis Warren and veterans Mikey Keene and Jake Garcia.
Focus on Development
With so many fresh faces, Whittingham and new offensive coordinator Jason Beck have to get these young guys up to speed, and fast. The team’s success could hinge on how quickly these quarterbacks develop.
Looking Ahead
As Michigan looks toward the 2026 season, Fowler-Nicolosi’s delayed arrival is both a headache and, maybe, a chance for someone unexpected to step up. The pressure’s on the young quarterbacks to fill the void for now.
Spring Practice
Spring practice is going to be huge for sorting out the depth chart. Coaches will be watching Tommy Carr and Colin Hurley closely, hoping one of them can handle backup duties if needed.
Summer Arrivals
When Fowler-Nicolosi finally shows up in the spring-summer term, he’ll bring some much-needed experience and probably shake up the competition. Until then, it’s a bit of a waiting game—and, honestly, a test of nerves for Michigan fans and coaches alike.
Big Ten Aspirations
Michigan’s got their eyes on the Big Ten, even with all the bumps in the road lately. The coaching staff is working hard to bring their young quarterbacks up to speed.
Getting Fowler-Nicolosi settled in is another big piece of the puzzle. Honestly, it’s tough to say how quickly everything will click, but that’s what makes it interesting, right?
If you want the full scoop, check out the article on MLive.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
