Baseball fans have spoken, and the votes for the MLB All-Quarter Century Team are in. This lineup showcases the best players at every position since the 2000 season.
Over 12,000 fans cast their votes, and the results have definitely sparked some heated debates. Controversial figures like Alex Rodriguez are at the center of it all, while legends like Ichiro Suzuki and Shohei Ohtani continue to shape their legacies.
Let’s dig into the top picks, the surprises, and, honestly, some of the wild discussions that have popped up thanks to this fan-driven project. If you want to check out the original article, you can find it here.
Find the best accommodations
Check availability at 5* hotels, guest houses and apartments rated "superb" or "exceptional" by visitors just like you.
NO RESERVATION FEES
CHECK AVAILABILITY FOR YOUR DATES HERE
Third Base: The Battle of Beltré and A-Rod
Third base turned into a showdown between Adrián Beltré, Alex Rodriguez, and Chipper Jones. Beltré barely edged out Rodriguez, grabbing 29.95% of the votes to A-Rod’s 29.78%.
Chipper Jones wasn’t far behind either, with 17.9% of the votes. The margin here was razor-thin, and fans weren’t shy about their opinions.
Why the Controversy?
A-Rod’s history with performance-enhancing drugs keeps this debate alive. Even so, thousands still backed him, which says a lot about how complicated fans’ feelings are toward players with controversial pasts.
Beltré’s steady performance and spotless reputation probably tipped the scale in his favor. He’s got the stats and the charm—people just like the guy.
Catchers: Posey vs. Molina
The catcher position was another tight race, with Buster Posey just squeaking past Yadier Molina. Posey pulled in 29.81% of the votes, while Molina ended up with 27.41%.
The Metrics Debate
Measuring a catcher’s value is tough, and fans can’t agree on the best way to do it. Posey’s an obvious Hall of Famer to many, but Molina’s defense and longevity kept him right in the hunt.
Right Field: Ichiro vs. Judge
Right field came down to Ichiro Suzuki and Aaron Judge. Ichiro took 39.3% of the votes, with Judge close behind at 37.4%.
Legacy vs. Power
Ichiro’s career stands out for his steady play and all those hits—he’s easy to root for. Judge, though, has been crushing it lately, drawing Babe Ruth comparisons for his power. Fans seem split between valuing long-term greatness and recent dominance.
Designated Hitter: Ohtani vs. Ortiz
Shohei Ohtani ran away with the designated hitter spot, earning 45.6% of the votes. David Ortiz followed with 37.6%.
Ohtani’s ability to pitch and hit at a high level has fans hooked. Ortiz is a legend, sure, but Ohtani’s doing things we’ve never really seen before.
Fifth Rotation Spot: Martinez vs. Halladay
The last spot in the rotation was almost too close to call. Pedro Martinez got 47.64% of the votes, while Roy Halladay finished at 46.68%.
Martinez’s peak years were absolutely electric, even if some of his best moments came before the 2000s. Halladay was a rock throughout the 2000s, always reliable. It’s tough to pick between a blazing peak and a long, steady run—fans clearly struggled with it.
Conclusion: The Fans Have Spoken
The MLB All-Quarter Century Team project really set off some passionate debates. Fans everywhere chimed in with their own takes, showing just how many different ways people see the game.
Some picks felt obvious. Others—like A-Rod making the list or those razor-thin votes between Posey and Molina—sparked a lot of heated talk.
If you want to dig into the results or just geek out over the details, check out the full article here.
Book Your Dream Vacation Today
Flights | Hotels | Vacation Rentals | Rental Cars | Experiences
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
