MLB Trade Deadline 2025: Teams to Sell or Chase Postseason

BOOK AWAY GAME TRAVEL NOW!
Flights | Hotels | Vacation Rentals | Rental Cars | Experiences

The MLB trade deadline always feels like a crossroads in the baseball season. Teams have to figure out whether to double down for a playoff run or start selling off pieces for a fresh start.

For 2023, it’s the same old story, but with new faces and tougher choices. Let’s dive into which teams should sell and which ones might want to hang in the postseason chase—at least, according to what the experts are saying right now.

Teams That Should Sell

Some teams, let’s be honest, are already out of the playoff picture as the deadline creeps up. These clubs usually have expiring contracts or veterans who could bring back younger talent in return.

Chicago Cubs

The Cubs just haven’t put it together this year. It seems like the smart move is to look ahead.

Guys like Marcus Stroman and Cody Bellinger could draw real interest from contenders. Trading them might finally bring in some much-needed youth for Chicago’s future.

St. Louis Cardinals

The Cardinals, who are usually steady, have had a rough go this season. Even so, Paul Goldschmidt and Nolan Arenado are still doing their thing.

If the front office moves them now, the return could kickstart a faster rebuild. It’s a tough call, but maybe it’s time.

Teams That Should Stay in the Postseason Race

Then there are the teams just on the edge of the playoffs. For them, adding a piece or two might make all the difference.

They’ve got a decent foundation and could use a little extra firepower.

San Francisco Giants

The Giants have surprised plenty of folks this year. Their core looks solid, but a bit more pitching depth wouldn’t hurt.

Advertisement
Advertisement


If they make the right moves, who knows? They could be a real threat in October.

New York Yankees

The Yankees have had their ups and downs, but they’re still in the mix. They need help, especially on the mound.

With their resources, they can swing big at the deadline if they want. It’s just a matter of whether they pull the trigger.

Key Players to Watch

The trade deadline always has its headline names. Here are a few players everyone seems to be watching right now.

Marcus Stroman

Stroman’s been a bright spot for the Cubs. He’s pitching well and could really help a contender down the stretch.

Plenty of teams will probably be calling about him.

Cody Bellinger

Bellinger, also with the Cubs, has shown flashes of his old MVP self. His bat could change the game for a team that needs offense.

Don’t be surprised if several contenders make a push for him.

Paul Goldschmidt

Goldschmidt keeps producing, even while the Cardinals struggle. His experience and steady bat make him a tempting option for teams hunting for veteran leadership.

Strategies for Buyers and Sellers

Approaches to the deadline depend a lot on where a team stands. Buyers and sellers have different goals and playbooks.

Buyers

Buyers need to zero in on what they’re missing most. Maybe it’s pitching, maybe it’s a big bat, or maybe just better defense.

They’ll probably have to give up some prospects to get what they want, which isn’t always easy.

Sellers

Sellers want to get the most they can for their assets. That usually means moving players with expiring deals or veterans who still have value.

The idea is to stack up talent for the future, even if it stings right now.

Impact of the Trade Deadline on the Postseason Race

The deadline can really shake up the playoff race. Teams that make smart moves might suddenly look like contenders, while others could fade fast.

Boosting Team Morale

Landing a key player can give a team a real jolt. Sometimes, that’s all it takes to spark a late-season run.

Long-Term Considerations

It’s easy to focus on the immediate payoff, but trades can echo for years. Teams have to balance going for it now with keeping the future in mind.

Conclusion

The MLB trade deadline always feels like a turning point in the baseball season. Teams have to weigh their options, trying to figure out what’s best for both now and the future.

Whether a team’s buying or selling, those moves can totally change the postseason race. Sometimes, it even shifts the entire direction of a franchise.

If you want a closer look at which teams should call it quits and which ones should keep pushing, head over to the full article on Yahoo Sports.

Joe Hughes

Book Your Dream Vacation Today
Flights | Hotels | Vacation Rentals | Rental Cars | Experiences

Joe Hughes is the founder of CollegeNetWorth.com, a comprehensive resource on college athletes' earnings potential in the NIL era. Combining his passion for sports with expertise in collegiate athletics, Joe provides valuable insights for athletes, fans, and institutions navigating this new landscape.

    Additional Reading:
Shop the Amazon.com Fan Shop and Fanatics Shop for gear from your favorite teams! Support our site at no cost to you.
Scroll to Top