The ongoing legal battles around the NCAA and NIL (Name, Image, Likeness) rights have taken another turn. The *House v. NCAA* settlement is under a microscope, and its outcome could really shake up college athletics.
At the center of this mess are the definitions and interpretations of “associated entities.” How these are defined could change the way NIL deals work in the future.
Understanding the *House v. NCAA* Settlement
The *House v. NCAA* settlement is packed with dense legalese. But at its core, it’s about two basic things: a deal’s a deal, and a judge can’t just rewrite it after the fact.
These principles matter a lot for the NCAA, especially when it comes to how “associated entities” are defined in the settlement.
The Role of U.S. Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins
U.S. Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins is the *House* settlement administrator. He’s set to take a closer look at these terms in a hearing on May 27.
His decision could shift the direction of NIL deals. Class counsel Steve Berman and Jeffrey Kessler claim that companies like Learfield, Playfly Sports, JMI Sports, and outside brand sponsors aren’t “associated entities.” That’s a big point in their argument.
Defining “Associated Entities”
The settlement, signed off by U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken, defines an “associated entity” as one closely tied to an NCAA member school for promoting the school’s athletics or its student-athletes. It also covers entities directed by a school’s athletics staff to help with recruiting or keeping athletes.
Even groups that have helped with recruitment or retention count as associated entities under this definition. The language is broad, maybe intentionally so.
Interpretation and Implications
When the *House* settlement was hammered out, most people figured these definitions covered boosters, collectives, and others using NIL as a cover for pay-to-play schemes. These so-called “fake NIL” deals are really just signing or retention bonuses dressed up as NIL contracts.
Real NIL deals? Those are more like the endorsement deals you see in pro sports—athletes making money off their name and image, not just getting paid to show up.
The Broader Right of Publicity
NIL sometimes gets talked about like it’s a brand-new legal right, but it’s really a slice of the broader right of publicity. That’s been around for ages.
Before 2021, college athletes couldn’t cash in on their NIL without risking their NCAA eligibility. Now, the *House* settlement says NIL payments from associated entities have to be for a real business reason and at fair market value.
The Role of the College Sports Commission
The College Sports Commission (CSC), created by the *House* settlement, decides if NIL payments meet those standards. If the CSC says no, there’s a neutral arbitration process to challenge that decision.
Right now, there’s an arbitration going on over the CSC’s rejection of millions in NIL deals for 18 Nebraska football players. It’s a bit of a mess.
The NCAA’s Position
The NCAA thinks class counsel is hoping Judge Cousins will make a broad ruling to sidestep this arbitration—and probably others down the line. Class counsel, on the other hand, argues that multimedia rights companies and brand sponsors aren’t associated entities because they’re just in it for their own profits.
These companies sell and manage schools’ intellectual property rights and do a lot of other business that benefits colleges and brands. It’s not always clear-cut.
Concerns Over Booster-Like Activities
Here’s where it gets tricky: multimedia rights companies now help broker NIL deals for athletes, sometimes even working with the same brands as the schools. That raises eyebrows about whether NIL is being used for recruitment, just like booster activities.
The NCAA and big conferences argue that letting these arrangements slide would basically gut the settlement’s NIL rules and revenue-sharing setup.
Maintaining a Distinction Between College and Pro Sports
The *House* settlement is supposed to keep some kind of line between college and pro sports. The NCAA says it doesn’t think multimedia rights companies and brand sponsors are always associated entities.
It depends on the details. If a company isn’t working with a school to help recruit or keep athletes, it probably doesn’t count as an associated entity.
The CSC’s Role in Determining Validity
The CSC is supposed to check if NIL deals are legit—do they have a real business purpose, like promotion or endorsement? And is the pay in line with what’s normal, not just a fancy way to pay someone to play?
If the CSC says no and an athlete disagrees, there’s that arbitration process. It’s not perfect, but at least there’s a way to appeal.
The Limitations of Judicial Authority
Maybe some folks now wish they’d written the settlement language differently, but that’s how compromise works. Both sides—NCAA and class counsel—said the language was fair enough at the time.
Judge Cousins can’t just add exceptions that weren’t negotiated. The settlement doesn’t mention a carve-out for brand sponsors or rights companies, and it wouldn’t fly for a judge to make one up now.
Legal Precedent and Contractual Integrity
Legal precedent says courts can’t just modify settlement terms or rewrite agreements that parties have already reached. Judges can interpret contracts, sure, but they’re not supposed to change the actual words.
A class action settlement is, at its core, a contract. Some places let judges use the “blue pencil rule” in noncompete and employment cases, but that doesn’t really fly with class action settlements.
Judge Cousins is going to have to look at what the settlement actually says—not what everyone in college sports wishes it said. That’s a tough spot, honestly.
The result here could shake up how NIL deals work and maybe even shift the whole college athletics scene. If you want to dig deeper, the full article’s on Sportico’s website here.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
