College football’s landscape is changing fast. Ever since Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) rights came into play in 2021, recruiting and competitive balance have started to look different.
At first, big names in the sport worried NIL would just make the rich programs richer. But, honestly, the latest data paints a messier, more interesting picture. A study by Tim Derdenger and Ivan Li shows talent is actually spreading out more, which makes games a lot less predictable.
Let’s dig into what this shift really means for college football.
The NIL Era: A Paradigm Shift in College Football
When NIL rights launched, experts like Nick Saban warned about a potential *caste system*—the idea that only the richest schools would get the best players. Instead, research is showing that NIL has actually evened things out a bit. The study, Does Personalized Pricing Increase Competition?: Evidence from NIL in College Football, tracked recruiting before and after NIL and found a clear uptick in talent spreading out.
Increased Talent Dispersion
The study’s biggest takeaway? Talent is more scattered across programs than ever. Before NIL, powerhouse schools pretty much hoarded five-star recruits. That’s not really the case now.
Elite players are open to schools that haven’t always been football royalty. Why? NIL gives them a shot at immediate money, not just the old-school prestige of a big-name program.
The odds of a five-star athlete making the NFL are about 65.5 percent, according to the study. That kind of probability makes the long-term benefits of picking a top-10 or top-25 school feel less important.
So, more players are chasing short-term NIL deals, and talent is spreading out in ways we didn’t see coming.
Competitive Balance and Unpredictability
This wider spread of talent has made college football way more competitive. Saturdays are unpredictable now. Underdogs are pulling off upsets that would’ve seemed impossible a few years ago.
It’s not just a feeling—betting lines and final scores back it up.
Notable Upsets
Some games from the 2025 season really show this off. Undefeated No. 2 Miami, a 13.5-point favorite, lost to Louisville in a wild 24-21 finish.
No. 10 LSU also stumbled, falling to No. 17 Vanderbilt despite being favored by two points. And unranked Arizona State shocked No. 7 Texas Tech, winning 26-22.
These upsets highlight how much more balanced things have gotten. Sportsbooks are catching on, too—odds are tighter, and games feel like real toss-ups.
The Trade-Off: Financial Gain vs. Prestige
Of course, there’s a trade-off here. Chasing NIL money might mean missing out on the prestige or development perks of a traditional powerhouse. But with a 65.5 percent shot at the NFL for five-star players, maybe that old prestige doesn’t matter as much as we thought.
Impact on Future Players
This shift might change how future athletes pick their schools. If NIL keeps driving decisions, the old power structure in college football could keep breaking down. That would mean more parity, more drama, and—honestly—a better show for everyone watching.
If you’re curious and want to dive into the details, check out the full study by Tim Derdenger and Ivan Li: The NIL Paradox: College Football Games Are Closer Than Ever, But At What Cost?
Conclusion
The NIL era has really shaken up college football. At first, people worried it would just make the gap between powerhouse schools and underdogs even bigger.
But, strangely enough, NIL rights have actually spread talent out more than anyone expected. Games feel less predictable now, and honestly, that’s made things a lot more fun for fans.
Players are seeing real money, right away, which is a huge change from how things used to be. There’s a buzz around every season—nobody’s quite sure how it’ll play out.
Where does this all lead? Hard to say. Everyone in the college football world is watching closely, waiting to see what sticks and what falls away.
If you want to dig deeper or just keep up with the latest twists, stick with our blog. We keep an eye on the research, the rumors, and all the trends swirling around the sport.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
