In a landmark case that could shake up college athletics, former Florida State quarterback Thomas Castellanos is suing the NCAA for portal access. This comes right after a Colorado judge granted a blanket waiver to 2022 athletes.
The NCAA’s new five-year eligibility rule left out the 2022 recruiting class, and that’s sparked a lot of outrage. Castellanos, who moved from Boston College to Florida State before the 2025 season, wants an injunction to let him enter the NCAA portal outside the usual window.
This legal fight is just one among many as athletes across the country push back against the NCAA’s latest guidelines.
The Background of the Case
The NCAA’s new age-based eligibility model gives athletes five years to play five seasons. But when they put this rule in place, they decided not to include the 2022 recruiting class.
That choice has triggered a wave of lawsuits from athletes hoping for one more season. U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney of Colorado recently granted a blanket waiver to athletes from the 2022 class, which just made things messier.
Thomas Castellanos’ Journey
Castellanos played for Florida State last season and put up impressive numbers: 2,760 passing yards, 15 touchdowns, plus nine more on the ground. Despite all that, he wasn’t picked in the 2026 NFL Draft, though one team did invite him to camp.
His path—from Boston College to Florida State, and now into a legal battle with the NCAA—shows just how complicated things have gotten for college athletes under these new rules.
The Legal Battle
Castellanos isn’t alone in challenging the NCAA’s guidelines. His attorneys, Ryan Downton and Darren Heitner, are pushing for an injunction so he can enter the portal outside the normal window.
This case matters because the NCAA is already juggling several lawsuits and a wave of negative public opinion. It’s not an easy spot for the organization.
The Impact of Judge Sweeney’s Ruling
Judge Sweeney’s decision gave athletes from the 2022 class another year of eligibility. But it didn’t let them enter the transfer portal, which is why Castellanos is asking for a separate injunction.
If he gets it, he’d have the chance to join a new team while the Colorado injunction is still active—without the NCAA coming after him.
The Broader Implications
Castellanos’ lawsuit could end up changing college sports in a big way. The NCAA is already under a microscope for its new eligibility rules and is lobbying Congress for the Protect College Sports Act (PCSA).
If the PCSA passes, every athlete would be immediately eligible to play. Attorney Ryan Downton even pointed out the irony: if that happens, Castellanos and all his clients would get to play this year.
The NCAA’s Struggles
The NCAA is getting hit with lawsuits from athletes who want eligibility under the new system. Coaches are scrambling to manage their rosters because nobody knows what’s going to happen next.
Public opinion isn’t on the NCAA’s side, and the organization is trying to hold onto its authority in a pretty tangled legal mess.
What’s Next for Thomas Castellanos?
Castellanos is waiting for the court’s decision on his injunction, and honestly, it’s tough to say what’ll happen next. Courts have been granting these injunctions more often, so maybe he’ll get the green light too.
This case—and others like it—will keep shaping the future of college athletics and whatever role the NCAA ends up playing.
The Role of the Courts
The courts have turned into a crucial battleground for athletes who want to challenge the NCAA’s new rules. Judges around the country keep granting injunctions, letting athletes keep playing while their cases move through the system.
This has made college sports feel unpredictable and, honestly, a bit chaotic. Every new ruling can shake things up and change what everyone expects next.
If you’re curious and want more details, you can check out the full article on Fox News’ OutKick Sports here.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
