Top College Football Coaching Hires of 2025-26: Best and Worst Graded

BOOK AWAY GAME TRAVEL NOW!
Flights | Hotels | Vacation Rentals | Rental Cars | Experiences

This year’s college football coaching carousel? Wild. Major programs like LSU, Penn State, and Florida all made big moves. As things start to settle, it’s worth sizing up the hires and what they might mean. Virginia Tech landed James Franklin, Kentucky parted ways with Mark Stoops—there’s a mix of risky gambles and long-term plays all over. Honestly, it’s hard not to get caught up in the drama.

Virginia Tech Hokies: James Franklin

Virginia Tech grabbed headlines by bringing in James Franklin. He’s got a real track record from his time at Vanderbilt and Penn State. Over 15 seasons, Franklin’s teams have racked up nine-win seasons and kept a .600-plus winning percentage. For a program that limped to 3-9 in 2025, this feels like a much-needed jolt.

Immediate Impact

Franklin’s already shaking things up with a recruiting class Hokies fans haven’t seen in a while. The school is backing him in the transfer portal too. It’s early, but the buzz is real.

Oklahoma State Cowboys: Eric Morris

Oklahoma State rolled the dice on Eric Morris, a coach with Texas roots and a knack for developing quarterbacks. Morris moved up fast—offensive coordinator at Texas Tech, then head coach at Incarnate Word, and just led Texas State to an 11-1 record.

Recruiting and Development

Morris brings deep recruiting ties in Texas, which is huge for the Cowboys. His work with QBs like Patrick Mahomes and Cam Ward stands out. If he gets the support he needs, Oklahoma State could be looking at eight-win seasons by 2028.

Kentucky Wildcats: Will Stein

Kentucky went bold, hiring Will Stein, Oregon’s 36-year-old offensive coordinator. He’s helped develop quarterbacks like Dillon Gabriel and Dante Moore. Fans are hoping his offensive mind can finally wake up Kentucky’s attack.

Long-Term Vision

Stein’s got local roots and real passion for the school, which should help with recruiting and fundraising. It might take a while, but the upside here is intriguing.

Advertisement
Advertisement

LSU Tigers: Lane Kiffin

LSU made headlines by landing Lane Kiffin after a high-stakes bidding war. Kiffin’s record isn’t quite as shiny as Brian Kelly’s, but his skill in the transfer portal and recruiting is tough to ignore.

Championship or Bust

There’s real pressure here. LSU expects more than just playoff appearances—they want titles. The school’s bet on Kiffin is massive, and the risk is obvious. Still, the ceiling is sky-high.

Auburn Tigers: Alex Golesh

Auburn pulled in Alex Golesh, fresh off a breakout run at South Florida. He turned that program around fast, which is impressive in itself.

Recruiting and Player Development

Golesh knows the SEC and has strong Florida connections. Auburn’s hoping his recruiting and player development can bring them back. With quarterback Ashton Daniels and wide receiver Cam Coleman, this season could get interesting.

Colorado State Rams: Jim Mora

Jim Mora’s move from UConn to Colorado State flew under the radar. He made UConn a winner—something most people thought was impossible these days.

Perfect Fit

Colorado State gives Mora a West Coast spot and a program with realistic goals. After some rough years, Mora could finally bring some stability. Might be worth keeping an eye on the Rams now.

Ole Miss Rebels: Pete Golding

After Lane Kiffin left, Ole Miss promoted defensive coordinator Pete Golding. His time under Nick Saban at Alabama and his recruiting chops make him an interesting pick.

Resource Allocation

With Kiffin’s salary off the books, Ole Miss can spend more on recruiting and staff. Golding’s never been a head coach before, though, so there’s some uncertainty. Still, he’s got the tools to make it work.

Florida Gators: Jon Sumrall

Florida took a chance on Jon Sumrall. He doesn’t have Florida ties and his record against ranked teams is mixed. His runs at Tulane and Troy were solid, but it’s fair to wonder how he’ll handle SEC pressure.

Patience Required

Sumrall needs time to adjust, and Gators fans might have to be patient. It could be a few seasons before things really start to click.

Oregon State Beavers: JaMarcus Shephard

Oregon State hired JaMarcus Shephard, who’s never been a head coach but has helped develop wide receivers at Washington and Alabama. He’s bringing over some staff from Alabama, which helps the optimism.

High-Risk, High-Reward

Shephard’s inexperience is a risk, but his player development and West Coast ties give this hire some real intrigue. Sometimes you just have to roll the dice.

BOOK AWAY GAME TRAVEL NOW!
Find the best accommodations
Check availability at 5* hotels, guest houses and apartments rated "superb" or "exceptional" by visitors just like you.
NO RESERVATION FEES
CHECK AVAILABILITY FOR YOUR DATES HERE
 

Michigan State Spartans: Pat Fitzgerald

Michigan State’s hire of Pat Fitzgerald got people talking. He had great years at Northwestern, but things went south at the end. The game’s changed a lot since his peak seasons from 2015 to 2018.

Mixed Reactions

Some fans are optimistic, others not so much. It’s a split crowd, and honestly, no one really knows how this will pan out.

Arkansas Razorbacks: Ryan Silverfield

Arkansas picked up Ryan Silverfield from Memphis, but the reaction has been pretty skeptical. He started strong at Memphis but struggled lately, so there’s some doubt about his fit in Fayetteville.

Uncertain Future

Silverfield’s inconsistency makes things murky for Arkansas. Fans aren’t convinced yet, and it’s hard to blame them.

Stanford Cardinal: Tavita Pritchard

Stanford’s hire of Tavita Pritchard raised some eyebrows. He’s a former offensive coordinator with deep program ties, but he’s been out of college football for three years. His stretch as OC wasn’t exactly a high point for the Cardinal, either.

Questionable Decision

Pritchard’s close relationship with Andrew Luck and his long run at Stanford don’t exactly inspire much confidence in this hire.

Honestly, Cardinal fans aren’t given much to get excited about here. It feels like a move that could easily backfire.

If you want to dig deeper into these coaching hires, check out the full article on Sportsnaut.

Joe Hughes
Joe Hughes is the founder of CollegeNetWorth.com, a comprehensive resource on college athletes' earnings potential in the NIL era. Combining his passion for sports with expertise in collegiate athletics, Joe provides valuable insights for athletes, fans, and institutions navigating this new landscape.

    Additional Reading:
Advertisement
Advertisement
Scroll to Top