College sports have changed dramatically over the past few years. The way athletes are paid isn’t what it used to be, and the whole collegiate athletics scene feels different now.
It all started with California’s Fair Pay to Play Act (SB 206) back in 2019. For the first time, college athletes could make money from their name, image, and likeness (NIL)—a huge shift in NCAA history.
Since then, 35 states have jumped in with their own laws. Now there’s a tangled web of rules and regulations across the country.
Let’s dig into how these NIL laws came to be, what they’ve done to college sports, and what’s next for student-athletes and schools.
The Genesis of NIL Laws: California’s Fair Pay to Play Act
California shook things up in 2019 by passing the Fair Pay to Play Act (SB 206). Suddenly, athletes could profit from their NIL rights, which had always been a big NCAA no-no.
The law tried to avoid conflicts with team contracts and made athletes disclose NIL deals. It was supposed to start in 2023, but honestly, it sped up the whole national conversation and got other states moving fast.
The Wave of State Legislation
Once California made its move, other states weren’t about to sit back. One after another, they rolled out their own NIL laws, each with its own quirks and hoops to jump through.
As of now, 35 states have some kind of NIL policy, whether it’s a law or an executive order. But these rules aren’t all the same—far from it.
- Disclosure requirements
- Permissible industries for endorsement deals
- Contract confidentiality
- Eligibility of high school athletes
Take Florida, for example. They passed their NIL law in 2020 and set it to kick in by July 2021, which kind of forced the NCAA’s hand. The NCAA had to set up interim rules so student-athletes could cash in on their NIL rights.
Some states, like Florida again, actually repealed their own laws later on. They didn’t want to end up stricter than the NCAA’s new rules, which makes sense, I guess.
Impact on College Athletics
With these laws in play, college sports look different. Athletes are signing endorsement deals, promoting stuff, and making real money—sometimes a lot of it.
It’s turned into a bit of a free-for-all, with bidding wars for top athletes. The market’s wide open now, and honestly, it’s a little wild.
The House v. NCAA Settlement: Direct Compensation for Athletes
Things got even more interesting in 2025 with the House v. NCAA settlement. Schools can now pay student-athletes directly—up to $20.5 million a year, on top of whatever they make from NIL deals.
This pool of money is supposed to grow every year, hitting $32.9 million by the end of the 10-year deal. Most of it goes to football and men’s basketball, which isn’t shocking since those sports bring in most of the cash.
Title IX Concerns
But here’s the tricky part: Title IX. That law says schools have to treat male and female athletes fairly, at least when federal money’s involved.
So, schools are trying to figure out how to split up these new funds without running into trouble.
Challenges and Opportunities in the NIL Era
The NIL world is still taking shape. There are plenty of new problems—and a few big chances—for athletes and schools.
Income Tax Liability
Some student-athletes are suddenly signing huge contracts. That means taxes, and probably more than a few headaches.
They might owe state taxes, and even have to pay up in states where they play away games. Lawmakers in seven states have tried to help by proposing bills to skip state income taxes on NIL earnings—Arkansas was the first to actually do it.
Employment Status of Student-Athletes
Now that schools are paying athletes directly, people are asking if student-athletes should count as employees. If so, what rights and benefits should they get?
It’s a hot topic, and honestly, there’s no easy answer yet.
Federal Involvement: Executive Order 14400
To try and wrangle the fast-growing NIL market, President Trump signed Executive Order 14400, called Urgent National Action to Save College Sports.
Basically, it bans “fraudulent” NIL deals—anything way above fair market value or involving third parties like NIL collectives. If schools don’t play by these rules, they could lose federal funding. That’s a pretty big stick.
Future Directions and Considerations
So, the NIL era is here, and honestly, state legislatures have a bigger hand in college sports than ever before. Lawmakers face a tough job—protecting young athletes from getting taken advantage of, but also making sure compensation stays fair.
The Institute for State Policy Leaders is putting on a Chaos in College Sports webinar. It’s a chance for experts and lawmakers to trade ideas, swap strategies, and maybe even argue a little about what’s next.
If you want to dig into how state laws have shaken up college athlete pay, check out this comprehensive article.
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
