The recent article on CBS Sports, titled Snyder’s Soapbox: The MLB Draft Will Never Come Close to the NFL Draft, So Let’s Stop Trying to Emulate It, brings up some interesting points about the big differences between the MLB and NFL drafts. The author says the MLB draft shouldn’t try to copy the NFL draft because the two sports have fundamentally different structures, player development paths, and levels of fan engagement.
This blog post digs further into those arguments. Let’s see why the MLB draft just doesn’t have the same spectacle or impact as the NFL draft.
Table of Contents
Find the best accommodations
Check availability at 5* hotels, guest houses and apartments rated "superb" or "exceptional" by visitors just like you.
NO RESERVATION FEES
CHECK AVAILABILITY FOR YOUR DATES HERE
The Fundamental Differences Between MLB and NFL Drafts
One of the main reasons the MLB draft can’t reach NFL draft levels of popularity is the difference in player development. In the NFL, drafted players usually make an immediate impact, stepping onto the field right away.
Fans and teams get instant gratification when a new player joins and contributes from day one. That kind of immediate payoff is a huge draw for everyone involved.
Player Development Pathways
But in baseball, things move a lot slower. MLB draftees typically spend years in the minor leagues before they even get close to the majors.
Fans don’t see their team’s draft picks make a difference for a long time, and honestly, it’s hard to stay excited about something that won’t matter for years. The MLB’s farm system just doesn’t offer the same instant excitement as the NFL’s approach.
Number of Rounds
There’s also the number of rounds to consider. The NFL draft has seven rounds, while the MLB draft can drag on for up to 40 rounds.
That’s a lot of picks, and it really dilutes the importance of each one. It’s tough for fans to keep caring when the process feels endless.
Fan Engagement and Media Coverage
Fan engagement is another crucial difference. The NFL draft has become a media spectacle, with wall-to-wall coverage on major sports networks.
Fans look forward to it every year, and the league has turned it into a prime-time event, complete with red carpets and deep-dive analysis. It’s a big show, no doubt about it.
Media Spectacle
The MLB draft, though, just doesn’t get that kind of attention. Even though coverage has improved a bit lately, it still can’t compete with the NFL draft’s hype.
Most years, the MLB draft gets overshadowed by the ongoing baseball season. It never really feels like a big standalone event.
Fan Involvement
The NFL draft also benefits from football’s overall popularity in the U.S. Football is king, and fans are obsessed with every part of the game, including the draft.
Baseball has plenty of fans, but it just doesn’t capture the same national attention. That naturally affects how excited people get about the MLB draft.
The Role of College Sports
College sports play a huge role in the NFL draft’s popularity. College football is massive, and fans follow top players closely from the start of their careers.
People already know many of the names entering the NFL draft, which adds to the hype and anticipation.
College Football vs. College Baseball
College baseball, by comparison, doesn’t have that kind of national following. Sure, there are dedicated fans, but the sport just doesn’t get the same attention as college football.
Most MLB draft prospects are unfamiliar to the general public, which makes it tough for fans to get excited about the event.
Star Power
The NFL draft often features players who are already household names. That star power makes the draft a can’t-miss event.
Meanwhile, the MLB draft is full of relatively unknown players. It’s hard to rally excitement for people you’ve never heard of.
Structural Differences in the Leagues
How the leagues are structured also plays a big role. The NFL uses a salary cap, so teams have a level playing field and a good draft can really change a team’s fortunes.
Salary Cap vs. Luxury Tax
MLB, on the other hand, runs on a luxury tax system. Teams with deep pockets can simply outspend the competition.
If a team messes up in the draft, it can just buy talent through free agency. That takes away some of the draft’s importance.
Team Building Strategies
In the NFL, teams rely on the draft to fill key roles and plan for the future. The draft is a central part of building a team.
But in the MLB, teams have more options. They can sign international players, make trades, and use the draft as just one piece of a bigger puzzle.
Conclusion: Embrace the Differences
The MLB draft just isn’t ever going to reach the wild popularity of the NFL draft. And honestly, that’s okay.
Baseball and football work with completely different systems. Player development in MLB takes a totally separate path, and that’s kind of the charm.
Why force MLB to mimic the NFL? Maybe it’s better to lean into what makes baseball special and connect with the fans who already love it.
Want to dig into this more? There’s a full article over at CBS Sports: Snyder’s Soapbox: The MLB Draft Will Never Come Close to the NFL Draft, So Let’s Stop Trying to Emulate It.
Book Your Dream Vacation Today
Flights | Hotels | Vacation Rentals | Rental Cars | Experiences
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews
